Wholesale Electricity Markets: Pricing Mechanisms and Operations

Deregulated electricity markets rely on sophisticated mechanisms to determine the price of power and coordinate the dispatch of generation to meet demand reliably and efficiently. Key concepts include nodal pricing, the Day-Ahead Market, and the Real-Time Market.

Nodal Pricing and Locational Marginal Pricing (LMP)

Most modern ISO/RTO markets (including ERCOT, PJM, CAISO, NYISO) utilize nodal pricing. This means the price of electricity is calculated at thousands of specific locations (nodes) on the transmission grid, such as generator connection points, load centers (substations), or trading hubs.

The price at each node is called the Locational Marginal Price (LMP). The LMP represents the marginal cost to serve the next increment (megawatt) of electricity demand at that specific location, at that specific time, considering several factors:

  1. System Energy Price: The cost of generating the next megawatt-hour (MWh) from the most economical generator available *if there were no transmission constraints*. This is often based on the bid price of the marginal generating unit dispatched system-wide.
  2. Congestion Component: An adder (or subtractor) reflecting the cost of transmission congestion. If transmission lines into an area are full (congested), more expensive local generation might need to be dispatched to meet load within that area. This difference in cost is reflected in a positive congestion component, making the LMP higher inside the congested area. Conversely, if cheap generation is "trapped" in an area due to export constraints, its LMP might be lower, reflecting negative congestion relative to other areas.
  3. Losses Component: An adder reflecting the marginal cost of transmission losses. As electricity flows through wires, some energy is lost as heat. Serving load farther away from generation incurs slightly higher losses. This component accounts for the cost of generating that extra bit of power to cover the marginal losses to deliver energy to that specific node.
LMP = System Energy Price + Congestion Component + Losses Component

LMPs provide crucial economic signals. High LMPs in an area signal scarcity or congestion, encouraging generators to locate there, transmission upgrades, or demand reduction. Low LMPs signal surplus generation or lack of transmission access.

Historical Note: Some older market designs used zonal pricing, where prices were averaged across broad zones. This was simpler but less efficient as it masked local constraints, often requiring the ISO to make costly out-of-market adjustments. The shift to nodal pricing improved market efficiency and price transparency.

Day-Ahead Market (DAM)

The Day-Ahead Market (DAM) is a forward financial market operated by the ISO, typically cleared one day before the actual operating day. In the DAM:

  • Generators submit offers indicating how much power they are willing to supply at various prices for each hour of the next day.
  • Load Serving Entities (LSEs) and large consumers submit bids indicating how much power they want to purchase at various prices for each hour.
  • Financial participants may submit "virtual" bids and offers (transactions not tied to physical load or generation) to arbitrage expected price differences between the DAM and Real-Time Market.

The ISO uses sophisticated optimization software (Security-Constrained Unit Commitment and Security-Constrained Economic Dispatch - SCUC/SCED) that considers these bids/offers, network constraints (transmission limits), generator operating parameters (ramp rates, start-up times), and reliability requirements (reserve needs). The software determines:

  • Which generating units should be committed (turned on) for the next day.
  • The economically optimal dispatch schedule for committed generation and scheduled load for each hour.
  • The resulting Day-Ahead LMPs at every node for each hour.

The DAM results are financially binding. Participants who buy or sell power in the DAM lock in those prices and quantities for the next day, providing a hedge against real-time price volatility. Most energy (often 80-95%) is scheduled and priced in the Day-Ahead Market.

Real-Time Market (RTM)

The Real-Time Market (RTM), sometimes called the spot market, operates closer to and during the actual operating hour. Its purpose is to balance the grid by addressing deviations between day-ahead schedules and actual real-time conditions (e.g., unexpected changes in demand, generator outages, forecast errors).

Key characteristics of the RTM:

  • Operates on a much shorter time interval, typically dispatching resources and calculating LMPs every 5 minutes (though some older practices or specific transactions might use 15-minute intervals).
  • The ISO issues dispatch instructions to generators to increase or decrease output based on current system needs.
  • Real-Time LMPs are calculated based on the marginal cost of meeting demand in that 5-minute interval, reflecting instantaneous supply/demand balance and constraints.
  • Participants who deviate from their Day-Ahead schedules settle the difference at the Real-Time LMP. For example, if an LSE bought 100 MWh day-ahead but its customers actually used 105 MWh, it buys the extra 5 MWh at the prevailing Real-Time LMPs. If a generator scheduled 50 MWh day-ahead but only produced 45 MWh, it must effectively "buy back" the 5 MWh shortfall at the Real-Time LMP.

Real-Time LMPs tend to be more volatile than Day-Ahead LMPs because they react to immediate events. The two-settlement system (DAM and RTM) encourages participants to be accurate in their day-ahead forecasts and schedules while providing a mechanism for efficiently managing real-time imbalances.

Market Settlement Intervals

The time interval used for financial settlement is crucial. Historically, some markets dispatched every 5 minutes but settled energy financially based on hourly averages. This could disadvantage fast-responding resources (like batteries or quick-start gas turbines) that might operate during a short, high-priced 5-minute interval but get paid a lower hourly average price.

Following FERC Order 825 (issued in 2016), all FERC-jurisdictional RTOs/ISOs were required to align their real-time energy and ancillary service settlement intervals with their dispatch intervals. This generally means moving to 5-minute settlements for real-time energy.

  • PJM transitioned to 5-minute settlements in 2018.
  • ERCOT (though not FERC-jurisdictional) transitioned from 15-minute to 5-minute settlements in 2021.
  • CAISO, NYISO, ISO-NE, MISO, SPP also operate with 5-minute real-time dispatch and settlement.

Shorter settlement intervals provide more accurate price signals, better compensate flexible resources for their services, and tend to reduce the need for "uplift" payments (out-of-market payments to make resources whole).

Day-Ahead markets typically still settle on an hourly basis, reflecting the hourly nature of DAM bids, offers, and schedules.

Further Reading: